Finding fits: a guide to plus-size vintage shopping across the us
The thrill of unearthing a perfectly preserved vintage dress or a unique, one-of-a-kind jacket is undeniable. But for plus-size shoppers, that thrill is often tempered by a frustrating reality: finding clothes that actually fit, let alone reflect the era's aesthetic, can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. While pop-up shops like Thick Thrift in Los Angeles and Pretty Girl Markets in Texas offer vital pockets of inclusivity, the historical sizing challenges – “people just used to be smaller!” – remain a persistent hurdle. Vogue has compiled a curated list of ten brick-and-mortar stores across the country offering a tangible, and crucially, try-on-able, vintage experience for plus-size individuals.
Beyond the algorithm: the joy of in-person discovery
The rise of online vintage marketplaces like Bad Moon Vintage and Goldies Vintage has undoubtedly broadened access, and destinations like Flower Child in Columbus, Ohio, and Moody Goose in San Francisco are commendable for their dedicated plus-size sections. However, this guide focuses on establishments where the majority, if not all, of the inventory caters to larger sizes, allowing for the vital tactile experience of trying clothes on before committing. It’s a return to the serendipitous nature of vintage shopping – stumbling upon a gem you never knew you were looking for.
Portland, maine: artemis plus size thrift
Just a stone’s throw from Portland’s historic Casco Bay Bridge, Artemis Plus Size Thrift is a regional treasure. Prices are generally reasonable, reflecting Portland’s laid-back vibe, but a keen eye can unearth retro gems amongst the beach tees and denim shorts. Size range: XL-5X+ Address: 96 Ocean Street, South Portland, ME 04106.
Brooklyn, new york: berriez
Emma Zack's Berriez in Bed-Stuy remains a beacon of hope in a dwindling landscape of sustainable plus-size options. The shop’s consistency – offering genuinely well-fitting and exciting pieces – is a rare and welcome find. Appointments are highly recommended. Size range: L-4X Address: 544 Park Avenue, Suite 510, Brooklyn, NY 11205.
Portland, oregon: i want seconds
Oregon's vintage scene benefits from a legacy of '90s riot grrrls who left their mark on the fashion landscape. I Want Seconds, Portland’s only fully plus-size resale shop, captures this spirit while hosting community events. Size range: XXS to 8X+ Address: 3204 SE Hawthorne Blvd, Portland, OR 97214.
Chicago, illinois: luvsick plus
For a brief Chicago visit, prioritize Luvsick Plus. Even straight-size shoppers will appreciate the impressive shoe and accessory selection, while plus-size customers will revel in the breadth of choices, from '90s tops to fitted '50s dresses, a style often difficult to source in larger sizes. Size range: XL-4X Address: 2706 North Sawyer Ave, Chicago, IL 60647.
Brooklyn, new york: plus bklyn
Since 2017, PLUS Bklyn in Williamsburg has been consistently delivering statement-making looks. Their dress and suit selection, in particular, is reliably exceptional. Size range: 0X-6X Address: 671 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222.
Los angeles, california: proud mary fashion
Despite Hollywood’s often-distorted portrayal of body types, Los Angeles embraces diversity. Proud Mary fashion champions this inclusivity, offering vintage finds alongside indie labels. Their accessory line, featuring playful slogans, adds an extra layer of personality. Size range: XL-6X Address: 5335 N Figueroa St, Los Angeles, CA 90042.
Seattle, washington: two big blondes
Two Big Blondes isn’t just a store; it’s a consignment hotspot. Expect a curated mix of Vince, Universal Standard, and true vintage pieces – all worth an in-person try-on, though online shopping is also available. Size range: L-6X Address: 2501 S Jackson St, Seattle, WA 98144.
The hunt for vintage treasures shouldn’t be limited by size. These stores represent a commitment to inclusivity, proving that style and sustainability can coexist—and that finding that perfect fit is within reach.